Mama Lucia Pizza

Reviews

• Jared L.

  star star star star star_border 19 October 2026

  The place gives a nice impression from the outside and looks clean and good for an Italian pizza place.  The selection of pizza by the slice was decent.  I ordered two slices and some garlic knots.   The food came quickly and was delicious.  The only drawback was the demeanor of the two gentlemen working this evening.   Both men seemed grumpy and generally annoyed that I was in their establishment giving them business.  Had it not been for two other groups eating, I'd have asked for my food to go.  Hopefully they were just having a bad day.  
  
  I would definitely eat again from this establishment, but my food would probably be takeout.

• Patrick P.

  star star star star_border star_border 17 October 2026

  Pizza Pizza
  
  We came, we saw, and we ate.
  
  We ordered 2 pies (1 for there and 1 to-go).   The gents serving us were not the most emotive.    Not happy, not sad, not mean.   Just take your order and move on.
  
  They were not extremely busy either.
  
  We ordered a half meat lovers / half pepperoni pizza.   We noticed that the pie was cooked all the way (hot) but did not have the upper burner affect - pepperoni's did not curl and develop the crispy edges.
  
  The first slice -
  - crust was on point - passed the stand test.
  - cheese was stringy like you want to see
  - pepperoni was meh
  - sauce - had good flavor but was a little acidic for my taste
  
  The second and third slices (because of the oil / grease) did not pass the stand test and became a little more gummy.
  
  This place sells individual slices.   I bet these are really good because they are all fresh.    While our pie was fresh, it just did not hold up.
  
  This was not a bad pizza and is based on my preference.  
  
  Check it out and develop your opinion.   I bet the slices are really good :)

• Barbara K.

  star star star star star_border 8 October 2026

  This is the best pizza in the North Hills, I kid you not.  We order pizza every Friday night and I try to order from some different pizza place each week.  Some I never go back to and some are regulars.  We order this last Friday and I am going back this Friday as well.  Excellent crust, great cheese, good sauce, YUMMY!
  I do not place much stock on how people feel about employees unless it had resulted in a bad situation.  No, they may not be the friendliest group but I am here to get good pizza.
  Their wings are darn good as well!

• Todd S.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 5 October 2026

  Poor service they canceled my order after 30 minutes
  No reason why. Choose another place if you want reliability

• Brian H.

  star star star star star 24 September 2026

  Outstanding! Originally from NYC, we ate lunch here while on a house hunting trip and thoroughly enjoyed it. We've spent the last 6 months trying to find it again, it was that good! Now we will be "regulars".